Bethel Pit
Natural Lake · Pike County, Indiana
Bethel Pit is a fishing destination in Pike County, in the forested hills of southern Indiana. The nearest city is Petersburg. The lake supports 5 documented species including Largemouth Bass, Bluegill, Channel Catfish, Black Crappie, and more. Use the DNR depth map to locate drop-offs, channels, and flats — last surveyed in 2018. The longer growing season means earlier spring fishing — bass move shallow by mid-March, and fall patterns extend into November. Browse nearby fishing guides, bait shops, and marinas to plan your visit.
Depth Maps
Bathymetric maps from the Indiana DNR Division of Fish & Wildlife. These maps show depth contours, vegetation, and bottom structure.
Fish Species
Species known to inhabit Bethel Pit. Click any species for a full fishing guide.
Other Lakes in Pike County
Plan Your Trip to Bethel Pit
- Check the latest DNR fishing report for current conditions
- Review Indiana fishing regulations for season dates and limits
- An Indiana fishing license is required for ages 18+ — buy online at IN.gov
Data sourced from Indiana DNR Division of Fish & Wildlife. Last verified: June 11, 2026. Learn how we maintain this data.